Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Twin Cities Homes: Asphalt, Metal, or Specialty Shingles?

The roof is a home's first line of defense, especially in the Twin Cities area. With cold, snowy winters, dramatic freeze-thaw cycles, and intense summer storms, Minneapolis-St. Paul homeowners need roofing materials that can stand up to the elements. At Signature Home Services, we’ve spent the last 22+ years helping local families choose and install roofing systems that offer performance, style, and long-term value.

Three of our area's most popular roofing options — asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and specialty shingles — each bring unique benefits. Here’s a breakdown of each and what to consider when making the right choice for your home.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common and budget-friendly roofing choice, with a lifespan of 15-30 years if properly installed and ventilated. They come in a wide variety of styles, colors, and finishes to complement any home's aesthetic.  Asphalt shingles are easy and quick to install, making them a great option when time is of the essence. They are ideal for budget-conscious homeowners who are looking for reliable performance.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is an incredibly durable and long-lasting option, lasting 40 to 70 years or more. It is an excellent choice for Twin Cities winters, as it can easily withstand snow loads, ice dams, and wind. The reflective surface of metal roofing improves energy efficiency in both summer and winter. It is also lightweight and recyclable, making it an eco-conscious choice. Although metal roofing has a higher upfront cost, it requires low maintenance and provides long-term savings.

Specialty Shingles

Specialty shingles, including architectural, designer, or synthetic, offer curb appeal and durability. They can even mimic the look of wood shake, slate, or other premium materials. While lifespan and maintenance will vary depending on the specific material, specialty shingles are generally more durable than basic asphalt shingles.

Key Considerations About Roofing Materials for Twin Cities Homeowners

When choosing a roofing material, Twin Cities homeowners have to consider several factors:

Climate Suitability:

• Asphalt handles snow and rain well but may degrade over time in freeze-thaw cycles.

• Metal roofing excels in shedding snow and resisting ice buildup.

• Specialty shingles are engineered for improved weather resistance.

Durability and Lifespan:

• Metal roofs lead in longevity, followed by specialty shingles, then asphalt.

• All three offer solid protection when properly installed and maintained.

Energy Efficiency:

• Metal roofs reflect heat and improve overall insulation.

• Specialty shingles may offer added insulation depending on the type.

• Asphalt is less efficient but can be paired with proper attic insulation.

Aesthetics:

• Asphalt comes in many colors and styles.

• Metal roofing has a sleek, modern look and comes in various finishes.

• Specialty shingles provide premium, high-end curb appeal.

Cost:

• Asphalt: most affordable upfront.

• Metal: higher initial investment but long-term savings.

• Specialty shingles: mid-to-high cost range, depending on material.

Maintenance:

• Asphalt requires occasional repairs.

• Metal is low-maintenance and resistant to pests and mold.

• Specialty shingles are created to mimic the look of high-maintenance materials like wood shake, but require far less maintenance.

Environmental Impact:

• Metal is 100% recyclable and energy efficient.

• Asphalt is less eco-friendly, but is improving with recycling programs.

• Many specialty shingles are made with sustainable or recycled materials.

Need Help Choosing the Right Roof for Your Twin Cities Home?

Signature Home Services installs asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and specialty shingles, and we’ll help you find the perfect fit for your home, lifestyle, and budget. Schedule your complimentary consultation today and let our experienced team guide you through a roofing solution built for Minnesota living.